Submission: National Inquiry into Children in Immigration Detention
Submissions to the National Inquiry into Children in Immigration Detention:
The Commission received more than 300 submissions for its Inquiry into Children in Immigration Detention, announced in November 2001.
Click on the links below to access submissions relating to specific issues raised by the Inquiry and submissions from individuals/ organisations attending public hearings.
- Evidence provided by ex-ACM staff
- Submission received from the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs
- Submissions focussing on Multiple issues
- Submissions on Legal issues
- Submissions on Health and Disability issues
- Submissions on the Psychological health of child asylum seekers
- Submissions on Education in Immigration Detention Centres
- Artwork Submitted to the Inquiry
- Public Hearing - Melbourne, 30 - 31 May 2002
- Public Hearing - Perth, 10 June 2002
- Public Hearing - Adelaide, 1 - 2 July 2002
- Public Hearing - Sydney, 15 - 17 July 2002
- Public Hearing - Brisbane, 5 August 2002
Submission received from the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs
The Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs prepared a submission in response to the terms of reference of the Commission's Inquiry into Children in Immigration Detention and to issues raised in the Background Papers.
To access the DIMIA submission visit: http://www.immi.gov.au/detention/hreoc
Submissions focussing on Multiple Issues
- Anonymous Visitor to Immigration Detention Centre
- Association of Children's Welfare Agencies (ACWA)
- Australian Association of Social Workers (AASW)
- Australian Catholic Migrant and Refugee Office
- Australian Catholic Social Justice Council
- Australian Human Rights Medallists
- Australian Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Workers Union
- Australian Parents Council Incorporated
- Catholic Welfare Australia
- Centacare Sydney
- Child & Family Welfare Association of Australia Inc.
- Coalition for Justice for Refugees
- Conference of Leaders of Religious Institutes
- Department of Justice, Victoria
- Ethnic Communities Council of Western Australia
- Ethnic Childcare, Family and Community Services Co-operative Ltd
- Good Shepherd
- Hunter Community Council
- Jesuit Refugee Service (JRS)
- Jon Stanhope MLA, Chief Minister ACT Legislative Assembly
- Len Baglow, B.Soc.Wk., G.D.U.R.P, Child Abuse Counsellor
- Marist Brothers' Province Centre
- Melbourne Catholic Migrant & Refugee Office
- Mercy Refugee Service
- Multicultural Council of the Northern Territory
- National Council of Women of Australia
- Nicola Roxon MP, Shadow Minister for Children and Youth
- Rural Australians For Refugees, Wangaratta Branch
- Salvation Army - Eastern Territory
- Samaritans
- Social Action Committee (SAC) of the Conference Leaders of Religious Congregations of Victoria (CLRCV)
- Social Justice Group at St John's College Dandenong, Victoria
- Social Responsibilities Commission, Anglican Province of Western Australia
- Tasmanian Government
- Terri Mayr
- Terry Zeeher, Clinical Psychologist
- Uniting Care Burnside
- United Nations Association of Australia (Incorporated)
- West Australians for Racial Equality
- Women Barrister's Association
- World Vision Australia
- Youth Justice Coalition
- YWCA of Australia
Submissions on Legal Issues
These submissions were made by individual lawyers and by bodies representing lawyers and the judiciary as well as organisations and individuals whose submissions dealt mainly with legal issues raised by the Inquiry:
- UNICEF
- Commonwealth Ombudsman
- Law Council of Australia
- National Legal Aid
- The Castan Centre for Human Rights Law, Monash University
- The International Commission of Jurists, Australian Section
- International Commission of Jurists WA Chapter and Women Lawyers Inc WA
- Australian Human Rights Centre
- Australian Lawyers for Human Rights
- Dr John Tobin, (University of Melbourne, Faculty of Law) - released prior to the Inquiry hearings in Melbourne
- Julian Burnside QC (and the KIDS submissions) - released prior to the Inquiry hearings in Melbourne
- The Law Institute of Victoria (endorses KIDS submission)
- Victorian Bar Council (endorses KIDS submission)
- The National Children's and Youth Law Centre
- The NSW Council for Civil Liberties
- Tasmanian Commissioner for Children
- Australian Catholic University
- Mr Krishna Rajendra
- Mr Anais D'Arville
- The Law Society of New South Wales
Submissions on Health and Disability Issues
Health
- Women's Rights Action Network of Australia
- Australian Association for Infant Mental Health (AAIMH)
- Melbourne International Health and Justice group
- Australian Reproductive Health Alliance
- Dieticians Association of Australia
- National Investment for the Early years
- Barbara Rogalla - former Woomera Nurse
- Australian Nursing Federation (Vic)
- Royal College of Nursing, Australia (RCNA) and the Australian Nursing Federation
Disability
Submissions on the Psychological health of child asylum seekers:
- Australasian Society for Traumatic Stress Studies (ASTSS)
- Australian Association for Infant Mental Health (AAIMH)
- Australian Association for the Welfare of Child Health (AWCH)
- Australian Early Childhood Association - NSW branch
- Australian and New Zealand College of Mental Health Nurses (Qld Branch)
- Australian Psychological Society
- Barbara Rogalla - former Woomera Nurse
- Barnardos Australia
- Brisbane Refugee Health Network and Refugee Claimants Support Centre
- Centacare Newcastle
- Centre for Multicultural Youth Issues (CMYI)
- Diversity Directions Inc
- Mental Health Council of Australia
- Public Health Association of Australia
- School of Education and Early Childhood Studies, University of Western Sydney
- Suicide Prevention Australia
Literature review on the psychological difficulties facing child refugees and asylum seekers
The Psychological Well Being of Child and Adolescent Refugee and Asylum Seekers: Overview of Major Research Findings of the Past Ten Years is a literature review undertaken by Trang Thomas, Professor of Psychology, and Winnie Lau, Clinical Psychology Researcher, at the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology. The review identifies several consistent findings by international studies on the psychological difficulties facing child and adolescent refugees and asylum seekers. For example, unaccompanied minors are at greater psychological risk than others. However, the review also points to the need for more research in certain areas. It includes extensive References and Suggested Readings.
Submissions on Education in Immigration Detention Centres:
- South Australian Department of Education, Training and Employment
- Australian Council of Deans of Education Incorporated
- Australian Federation of University Women Inc.
- Centre for Multicultural Youth Issues (CMYI)
- National Catholic Education Commission (NCEC)
- NSW branch of the Australian Early Childhood Association
- Queensland Independent Education Union (QIEU) Equity Committee
- Queensland Teachers' Union
- United Nations Youth Association of Australia
Artwork Submitted to the Inquiry
The following poems and drawings were submitted to the inquiry.
- Drawings provided by a child who has been in detention at Port Hedland IRPC for 22 months
- Two poems and a drawing provided by the mother of a child at Woomera IRPC
- Two drawings provided by a child at Woomera IRPC
- Drawing provided by a former child detainee in a focus group of the Inquiry
- Comments made by former child detainee on cover of HREOC Report, Those who've come across the seas
Public Hearing - Melbourne, 30 - 31st May 2002
Public hearings for the National Inquiry into Children in Immigration Detention were held in Melbourne on 30th and 31st May 2002.
The following people were scheduled to appear. Submissions received from these individuals/ organisations have been made available where possible.
Thursday 30th May from 2pm
- Grant Mitchell (Asylum Seekers Project, Hotham Mission)
- Marc Purcell (Justice for Asylum Seekers)
- Barbara Rogalla (former Woomera nurse)
- Julian Burnside QC et al (KIDS)
Friday 31st May from 11am
- Lyn Bender (former Woomera psychologist)
- John Tobin (University of Melbourne, Faculty of Law)
- Dr Jill Sewell (Alliance of Professionals Concerned about the Health of Asylum Seekers & their Children)
- Scott Phillips and colleagues (Melbourne International Health and Justice Group, RMIT)
Public Hearing - Perth, 10 June 2002
The Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission's National Inquiry into Children in Immigration Detention visited Western Australia from 10 to 19 June and held a public meeting in Perth on 10 June 2002.
The following people were scheduled to appear. Submissions received from these individuals/ organisations have been made available where possible.
- Ms Mary-Anne Kenny - Southern Communities Advocacy Legal & Education Service Inc
- Dr Judyth Watson - Coalition Assisting Refugees after Detention (CARAD)
- WA Government: represented by Kerry Ross, Maree De Lacey, Tara Gupta, Margaret Banks, Judith Chernysh, Dr Aaron Groves
- Dr Annie Sparrow & Dr Paul Carroll - Alliance of Professionals Concerned about the Health of Asylum Seekers and their Children
Public Hearing - Adelaide, 1 - 2 July 2002
The Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission's National Inquiry into Children in Immigration Detention visited South Australia from 27 June - 3 July and held a public meeting in Adelaide from 1 - 2 July 2002.
Submissions received from individuals/ organisations in South Australia have been made available where possible.
- Ms Tina Dolgopol, Action for Children South Australia
- Dr Ros Powrie, Australian Association for Infant Mental Health
- Ms Rosemary Steen and Ms Julie Redman, SA Coalition for Refugee Children
- Ms Colleen Fitzpatrick, Lutheran Community Care
- Ms Sue Park, Ms Beverley Hartigan, The Association of Major Charitable Organisations (SA) inc
- Ms Joy de Leo, Mr Janusz Mikos, Department of Multicultural Affairs, SA
- Mr John Halsey, Department of Education, SA
- Ms Inese Petersens, Former Woomera teacher
Public Hearing- Sydney, 15 - 17 July 2002
The Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission's National Inquiry into Children in Immigration Detention held a public meeting in Sydney from 15 - 17 July 2002.
Submissions received from individuals/ organisations in New South Wales have been made available where possible:
- Amnesty International, Australia
- Council of Social Service of NSW (NCOSS)
- Keysar Trad - Lebanese Muslims Association
- UNSW Centre for Refugee Research and the Australian National Committee on Refugee Women
- International Commission of Jurists, Australian Section
- Multicultural Disability Advocacy Association of NSW
- People with Disabilities
- UNICEF Australia
- United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees
- Refugee Advice and Casework Service
- National Ethnic Disability Alliance
- Australian Muslim Women's Association
- Refugee Review Tribunal
- Asylum Seekers Centre
- Chilout (Children Out of Immigration Detention)
- NSW Institute of Psychiatry and the Alliance of Professionals Concerned about the Health of Asylum Seekers & their Children
- (Fr) Frank Brennan SJ AO, Uniya Jesuit Social Justice Centre
Public Hearing - Brisbane, 5th August 2002
The Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission's National Inquiry into Children in Immigration Detention held a public meeting in Brisbane on 5th August 2002.
Submissions received from individuals/ organisations in Queensland have been made available where possible:
- Rohan Vora, Gaby Heuft, Margot Salom, Brisbane Refugee Health Network
- Ms Rasheeda Joseph, Ms Frederika Steen, Sr De Lourdes Jarrat, Alec Shabanz, Romera Centre
- Ms Camilla Cowley, Tiger 11 Soccer Team
- Kirsten Hagon (accompanied by four Australian high school students), Amnesty Schools Network
- Ms Ally Wakefield, Queensland Program of Assistance to Survivors of Torture and Trauma & David Batholomew, Youth Advocacy Centre
Statements about individuals
The Commission agreed to suppress names of individuals in published submissions where it is alleged that those individuals have acted inappropriately or illegally. The objective of this is to avoid publicity about an individual when there has been no opportunity to test the claims made against him or her.
This decision is in accordance with the Directions issued by the Human Rights Commissioner on 19 April 2002 entitled 'General Directions by the Human Rights Commissioner: Preservation of Anonymity and Limitations on Publication.' These directions are to be found on the Commission's website at: http://www.humanrights.gov.au/human_rights/children_detention/privacy.html
Disclaimer
The Commission was publishing these submissions without modification for public information and to facilitate comment. The submissions may contain errors and their publication does not represent any finding by the Commission about the matters contained in them.